These architectural drawings were shown at a public meeting held by McKibbon Hotel Group officials to explain their proposed hotel project to residents. Asheville City Council set a public hearing date of Sept. 11 to hear from the public, then decide whether to allow the project to move forward. McKibbon also has a website up to provide info at http://haywoodfacts.com/.
The proposal has been in the works for years. It is controversial because church officials with the historic Basilica of St. Lawrence don’t want a hotel on the nearby property, and have made their own pitch for a development. There’s a website in support of the basilica option, http://www.stlawrenceplaza.com/.
Meanwhile, there are many residents who want the piece of city-owned property where the hotel is proposed to be made into a park.
RECENT POSTS
Asheville Proper, a new steakhouse, planned for downtown Grove Arcade
December 9, 2019At Asheville Proper, ribeye, porterhouse, NY strip and other classic cuts of meat will be cooked over a wood-fired flame on a custom grill.No CommentsBernstein Family Christmas Spectacular offers one last holiday escape at Asheville’s Magnetic Theatre
November 21, 2019This year's show marks the 10th, and last, staging of the of raucous, irreverent play that's become a favorite holiday escape in Asheville.3 CommentsBuncombe tourism officials call barrage of criticism divisive, untrue
November 20, 2019Buncombe TDA members responded to a recent opinion piece criticizing the tourism board.4 CommentsParisian Hotel in downtown Asheville coming back for review
November 19, 2019The hotel proposal was approved before the current one-year moratorium on new hotel projects in Asheville.No CommentsHere’s how to enjoy Christmas Jam weekend in Asheville without the main jam
November 18, 2019The two-day Kevn Kinny Songwriter Jam set for Jack of the Wood on Dec. 13 and 14 is just one of the ways to enjoy Christmas Jam weekend in Asheville.No CommentsBluegrass band observes a growing Asheville in ‘Cold Mountain Town’ track
November 18, 2019Ty Gilpin, Unspoken Tradition's mandolin player and the song's writer, talks about the song, its message and the traditions of mountain music.No CommentsAsheville Citizen-Times awaits layoffs, consolidation after merger deal
November 17, 2019The new company, which will be called Gannett, will be focused on establishing a business model that puts digital offerings first.1 CommentNewSong music competition show set for Saturday at Isis Music Hall in West Asheville
November 15, 2019This year’s grand prize winner will receive a fully funded six-song EP, recorded and mixed at Asheville own Echo Mountain Recording Studios, and more.No CommentsChristmas Jam 2019 canceled in Asheville as organizers plan for 2020
November 13, 2019The Songwriter Jam, a two-day event set for Dec. 13-14 at Jack of the Wood, will feature Asheville musicians on the same weekend planned for Christmas Jam.1 CommentLady Folk at Ambrose West will spotlight three Asheville songstresses on Nov. 21
November 7, 2019The Lady Folk showcase will feature Whitney Moore of Queen Bee and the Honeylovers; Jane Kramer; and Christy Barrett of the Christy Lynn Band.No CommentsAsheville development updates: Large downtown mixed-use proposal set for P&Z hearing
November 6, 2019At least 10 percent of the residential units proposed for the Coxe/Asheland development will be designated as affordable units, offered at 80 percent AMI.No CommentsWoodstock legend Melanie to perform Asheville house concerts
November 5, 2019In this 50th anniversary year of Woodstock, one of its special stars is set to play a house concert series Nov. 16 and 17.No CommentsRussell Crowe spotted at Grey Eagle music hall in Asheville
November 3, 2019Actor Adam Goldberg, who starred with Crowe in the Hollywood hit "A Beautiful Mind," was also at The Grey Eagle.No CommentsAt Winter Lights, 500,000 lights will festoon North Carolina Arboretum
November 2, 2019The light show kicks off with a lighting ceremony in downtown Asheville on Nov. 22.No CommentsBuncombe TDA awards Asheville festivals and events total of $86,500
November 1, 2019Here are two from the list of about 20 awardees: Winter Lights at The N.C. Arboretum received $10,000, the Sourwood Festival in Black Mountain received $9,000.1 CommentAsheville food makers Roots Hummus, Munki Foods, more spotlighted in Nov. 7 taste, talk
October 30, 2019Founders of Looking Glass Creamery, Firewalker Hot Sauce and Postre Caramels are the other featured guests.No CommentsAt Taste of Asheville, sample bites and beverages from 50 AVL indy restaurants
October 29, 2019The Taste of Asheville is set for Nov. 21 at The Venue in Asheville.No CommentsAsk A Woman AVL: I’m paralyzed by a crush on my friend; help!
October 26, 2019Stop pining away in fantasyland and go for it.No CommentsHot Sheet: Original Papa Nick’s now open at French Broad River Brewing
October 19, 2019Also, a new baker's collaborative in Asheville is planning its first pop-up even on Wednesday at Fleetwood's in West Asheville, and more.No CommentsAsheville development roundup: New Haywood Street condos planned, more
October 18, 2019Also, plans for the major redevelopment of the Sears property at the Asheville Mall have once again been continued, and more.No CommentsThe Nude Party kicks off concerts at amphitheater in Asheville’s Montford neighborhood
October 17, 2019Kitty Tsunami and Self-Help will join The Nude Party on stage for the Wednesday evening show.No CommentsNew mixed-use project, the Bier Haus, planned for downtown Asheville
October 12, 2019The Bier Haus project calls for the renovation of the building at 34 S. Lexington Ave., which is adjacent to Button & Co. bagel shop.No CommentsAshvegas Hot Sheet: The Asheville hangover nanny, and more
October 8, 2019Also, Down Dog Bar & Yoga Studio is a new business in the works that would combine a yoga studio with a dog bar, and much more.No CommentsAshvegas Hot Sheet: Popeyes open on Airport Road in South Asheville
October 6, 2019Also, Chef Steven Goff of AUX Bar in Asheville was recently named the North Carolina Restaurant and Lodging Association's "chef of the year" following a cook-off competition.No CommentsChow Chow food festival in Asheville, reviewed
October 5, 2019Chow Chow crowned a new culinary star on the Asheville food scene: Benne on Eagle restaurant.No CommentsCURVE Studios to celebrate 30th anniversary in Asheville River Arts District
October 3, 2019There will also be a dedication of a special "chair arch" in the CURVE Studios garden to help mark the occasion.No CommentsSovereign Remedies’ recipe for success: host a James Beard House dinner
October 2, 2019How an Asheville restaurant crew went to New York City to serve up a prestigious dinner at the James Beard House.No CommentsAsheville musicians mourn death of Grateful Dead lyricist Robert Hunter
October 1, 2019"Robert Hunter’s lucid visions painted a landscape across my most formative years," says Josh Blake.No CommentsIt’s wheels up on major Asheville Regional Airport expansion
September 30, 2019Airport officials recently agreed to contract with the architectural and engineering firm Gresham Smith for the design and engineering of a multi-million dollar airport terminal renovation and expansion project.No CommentsNew downtown Asheville police district coming online soon
September 17, 2019The downtown police district proposal faced criticism when it was first proposed about two years ago.No Comments
20 Comments
Pingback: New downtown Asheville hotel planned
Pingback: 2012 year in review: Top Ten local news stories
Actually, skyrocketing room rates suggest that demand for downtown hotels is at an all time high. Some more rooms in an attractive building could add some nice price competition.
I don’t really get why we need/want another hotel. There is the Indigo a block away, the Haywood Park hotel down the street and the brand new Aloft hotel on Biltmore Ave as well as Downtown Inn & Suites, numerous B&Bs, etc. Overkill? Probably. Honestly, I don’t have an alternative. A park would probably attract more vagrants/transients where APD would have to stretch out that way from Pritchard Park. Anything is better than the worn out parking lot that is there now though. More hand wringing and bitching by the people of AVL most likely. Oh well. Can’t please everybody.
Agreed 100% on the need to increase the density and intensity of development wherever appropriate, and downtown is obviously an appropriate place.
In another presentation from the same meeting, McKibbon stated that for competitive hotels in Asheville in 2011, the average occupancy year round was 73%, and projected to be 78% in 2012. Hotels are generally said to be profitable above 60% occupancy.
I’m not a big fan of the actual design. Somehow somebody along the way decided that giving buildings a 1-2 story “snout” along the sidewalk, with a small stepback of 10 or 20 feet, and then rising to their full height from there, would make them more sensitive to their context. I contend that it makes the building look unnatural and weird. No historical tall buildings in Asheville do anything like this. I guess this is just adhering to whatever is required by the zoning codes, so this is supposedly what we want, but still.
Regardless, I prefer a somewhat awkward-looking design that follows sound urban principles over a weed filled parking lot and condemned buildings any day of the week.
How exactly is it not an appropriate place for a park?
It’s not necessarily that the location is inappropriate for a park but that the situation is inappropriate for a park. In short, the city has no money to turn this patch of concrete and decaying buildings into a lush green oasis. There are perhaps ways of obtaining that money but all of them would require the state to change laws regarding hospitality tax money distribution.
That is an unrealistic proposal. Why? The state and its Republican government is openly hostile to urban areas in general and to Asheville in particular. You should not expect help from an entity that is working so hard to strip the city of its airport, the Ag Center, and its water system. Therefore, if there is no money now, there will not be any money later.
Additionally, thanks to that Republican government, it is now effectively illegal for cities to expand their boundaries. That means that any new tax revenue generated inside the city of Asheville will have to come from growth and development inside the city limits. This means the city will have to use its existing land to its utmost, smartest use — and in this case that means a tax revenue-generating commercial project smack in the heart of downtown.
In a nutshell, there is no money to build a park and none will be forthcoming, and the city needs the taxes.
If you want to demand a park, do it productively and get on the city’s case about developing the Overlook Park on Beaucatcher Mountain.
The idea that green space has to cost exorbitant amounts of money is so ridiculous. Witness NYC community gardens–turning derelict space, including unused parking lots, nasty trash filled spaces, etc into gorgeous, vibrant gardens. It doesn’t take lots of money, it just takes people. So the idea that there is “no money to build a park” is completely backwards. http://www.greenthumbnyc.org/gardensearch.html
Now sure, if you want to have a city-built developed garden, they’ll find a way to make it cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, no doubt.
Workah, you’re not just talking about putting some plant pots in a parking lot. There are derelict buildings on this plot of ground too. Are they filled with asbestos or other hazardous materials? Do you know how much abatement would cost if they were?
From everything I’ve heard, the people who most want a park want something like Pritchard Park in this space. That would mean removing the pavement, taking down the buildings and decontaminating the area of any hazardous dust they might generate, moving utility pipes, and God knows what all else.
None of that is cheap. The statement that it would cost quite a pretty penny to build a park on a paved and developed urban lot is not at all backward.
I completely agree. The city must do everything it can to gain revenue against a state government that wants to choke it off at every turn and funnel everything to state control. This is interesting coming from a party that talks about small government but obviously walks to a totally different tune. Also, the comparison to NYC is about as irrelevant as you can get. I can understand the need for more green space in a concrete jungle of over 8 million people. C’mon folks! We practically live in a giant park! I don’t see any problem whatsoever with responisble urban growth in downtown Asheville. We are a growing city. We need that space developed and the subsequent economic benefits of it.
Well stated.
Other communities in the city actually need parks & green space – let’s put money into helping those communities if we really want to support the idea of parks.
The people of PARC just don’t want to deal with the construction & a hotel. They are wasting tax payer dollars and have Councilman Bothwell in their pocket (for shame – he was supposed to be against such obvious buyouts as a politician). Let this process move on already.
Build the hotel and in 50-75 years maybe it will convert to mixed use business & housing like the other old hotels of AVL’s previous glory days.
It looks like the architects have done a good job of being respectful and complementary to the basilica and Asheville’s own eclectic, somewhat eccentric style. It will be a good addition aesthetically and economically to the community. Perhaps those who did not “vote” in the PARC survey could speak up here.
People Advocating Relentless Complaining …
PARC’s leading members live right next door – it seems really more selfish about them not wanting to deal with and hear construction than about what is best for the community. This is a good compromise w/ the plaza & design & infinitely better than the eyesore that currently exists. I support parks, but this is not an appropriate space for one.
Looks great.
I like it as well, especially the version that re-routes Page. That area has always been a little confusing.
I hope it gets built too. It looks fine to me. My fear is that PARC will pitch such a fit that the lot ends up staying just the way it is for another decade or two.
Which would suit them just fine, I suspect. Derelict buildings and a parking lot — anything is better than new construction!
This proposal looks great. We get a nice looking hotel, tax revenue, some open space in front, and we improve what is now an ugly parking lot. I think the design compliments downtown and the Basilica. I hope it gets built.
and quite a bit of primo new retail space on Haywood Street …